The electric vehicle (EV) market has witnessed remarkable growth, with Tesla at the forefront of innovation and performance. Two models that have significantly impacted the market are the Tesla Model Y Long Range AWD 75kWh and the Tesla Model S 75. These vehicles, though both Teslas, cater to different segments of the market, offering distinct features and performance characteristics. In this article, we will delve into a detailed comparison of these two vehicles, exploring their performance, battery and charging capabilities, design and dimensions, infotainment systems, comfort, and safety features. By the end of this comparison, you will have a clear understanding of how these models stack up against each other and which might be the better choice for your needs.
Key Specifications
| Specification | Tesla Model Y Long Range AWD 75kWh | Tesla Model S 75 |
|---|---|---|
| Launch Year | 2019 (Released 2020) | 2016 (Released 2016) |
| Base Price (USD) | $61,000 | $64,500 |
| Base Price (EUR) | €64,500 | €61,000 |
| Base Price (GBP) | £58,000 | £58,000 |
| Power | AWD 378 kW (514 hp) | RWD 285 kW (387 hp) |
| Torque | 440 Nm (325 lb-ft) | 440 Nm (325 lb-ft) |
| Acceleration (0-100 km/h) | 5.0 seconds | 5.5 seconds |
| Top Speed | 217 km/h (135 mph) | 225 km/h (140 mph) |
| Battery Capacity | 75 kWh | 75 kWh |
| Range | 507 km (WLTP) | 401 km (EPA) |
| Charging Time (AC) | 11 kW, 0-100% in 7 hours 31 min | 11 kW, 0-100% in 7 hours 45 min |
| Charging Time (DC) | 250 kW, 10-80% in 30 min | 150 kW, 10-80% in 40 min |
| Dimensions (L x W x H) | 4750 x 1920 x 1624 mm | 4979 x 1964 x 1445 mm |
| Weight | 1979 kg | 2027 kg |
| Trunk Capacity | 854 l (max 2041 l) | 745 l (max 1645 l) |
| Autopilot | Yes | Yes |
| Safety Ratings | NCAP 2022: 5 stars | NHTSA 2013-2022: 5 stars |
Performance
When it comes to performance, the Tesla Model Y Long Range AWD 75kWh and the Tesla Model S 75 offer impressive figures, but they cater to different driving experiences. The Model Y, with its 378 kW (514 hp) all-wheel drive (AWD) system, delivers robust acceleration, achieving 0-100 km/h in just 5 seconds. This makes it ideal for those who seek a dynamic and responsive driving experience. The torque output of 440 Nm ensures smooth and powerful acceleration, whether you’re navigating city streets or highways.
On the other hand, the Model S 75, equipped with a rear-wheel drive (RWD) system, produces 285 kW (387 hp), allowing it to reach 0-100 km/h in 5.5 seconds. While slightly slower than the Model Y, it offers a more traditional sedan-like driving feel, with a focus on luxury and refinement. The top speed of the Model S is slightly higher at 225 km/h (140 mph), compared to the Model Y’s 217 km/h (135 mph), which might appeal to those who occasionally crave higher speed driving.
Battery and Charging
Battery capacity and charging efficiency are critical factors for any EV, and both models excel in this department. The Model Y Long Range AWD features a 75 kWh battery, providing a WLTP range of 507 km (509 km EPA). This is slightly more than the Model S 75, which offers a range of 401 km (EPA) or up to 480 km (NEDC). The difference in range can be attributed to the Model Y’s slightly more efficient powertrain and aerodynamics.
Charging capabilities are where the Model Y outshines the Model S. The Model Y supports Supercharger V3 technology, allowing for a maximum DC charging rate of 250 kW, which can charge the battery from 10% to 80% in just 30 minutes. In contrast, the Model S uses the older Supercharger V2, with a maximum charging rate of 150 kW, taking 40 minutes for a similar charge. This difference in charging speed could be a significant factor for those who frequently undertake long journeys and require quick top-ups at charging stations.
Both models are equipped with 11 kW AC charging capability, though the Model S also offers a higher 16.5 kW AC charging option, which slightly reduces charging time. Despite this, the overall advantage in charging speed and efficiency goes to the Model Y.
Design and Dimensions
Design and dimensions are where these two vehicles diverge significantly. The Tesla Model Y is designed as a compact SUV, offering a higher seating position, more interior space, and the option for a third-row seat, making it a versatile choice for families or those who need extra cargo space. Its dimensions are 4750 x 1920 x 1624 mm, making it shorter but taller than the Model S. This gives it a more commanding road presence and better visibility.
The Model S, however, is a traditional luxury sedan, measuring 4979 x 1964 x 1445 mm. Its sleek and low profile, coupled with a slightly longer wheelbase (2960 mm compared to the Model Y’s 2890 mm), contributes to a more stable and comfortable ride, especially at higher speeds. The lower center of gravity in the Model S also enhances handling, making it a joy to drive on winding roads.
In terms of cargo space, the Model Y offers more practicality with 854 liters of trunk space, expandable to 2041 liters when the rear seats are folded. The Model S provides 745 liters, expandable to 1645 liters. The Model Y also has a higher ground clearance, making it more suitable for light off-road conditions or rougher urban environments.
Infotainment and Displays
Tesla has always been at the cutting edge of in-car technology, and both the Model Y and Model S come equipped with state-of-the-art infotainment systems. The Model Y features a 15-inch central touchscreen that controls almost every aspect of the vehicle, from navigation to climate control. The interface is intuitive, responsive, and regularly updated via over-the-air software updates, ensuring that it remains at the forefront of automotive technology.
The Model S ups the ante with a larger 17-inch central touchscreen and an additional 12.3-inch driver’s display that provides essential driving information directly in the driver’s line of sight. This dual-screen setup offers a more immersive experience, allowing drivers to access navigation, media, and vehicle settings more conveniently. However, the larger screen and additional display in the Model S may appeal more to tech enthusiasts who appreciate a more integrated driving experience.
Both vehicles support connectivity features such as Bluetooth, Wi-Fi, and USB ports, but the Model S also includes more advanced features such as a customizable driver’s display and enhanced voice control options. However, the Model Y is not far behind, with similar connectivity options and seamless integration with Tesla’s mobile app, providing remote access to vehicle controls, charging status, and location tracking.
Comfort and Convenience
When it comes to comfort and convenience, the Model Y and Model S both excel, though they cater to different preferences. The Model Y offers a more spacious interior, particularly in the rear seats, thanks to its taller and more upright design. This is especially beneficial for taller passengers or families who need to accommodate child seats. The Model Y also offers heated seats for all passengers, including those in the optional third row, making it a great choice for colder climates.
The Model S, while slightly less spacious, focuses on luxury and refinement. The seats are more contoured and supportive, offering a more premium feel, particularly for long-distance driving. Both vehicles come with an all-glass roof that adds to the sense of space and provides an expansive view of the sky. However, the Model S benefits from a more advanced air suspension system that adjusts the ride height and firmness based on driving conditions, ensuring a smoother and more comfortable ride over varying road surfaces.
Parking aids in both models include front and rear sensors, a reversing camera, and Tesla’s Autopark feature, which can automatically park the car in tight spaces. The Model S offers a slight edge in terms of ride quality and overall luxury, but the Model Y provides more practicality and versatility, particularly for families or those who require additional cargo space.
Safety Features
Safety is a paramount consideration for Tesla, and both the Model Y and **
Model S** have achieved top safety ratings in various crash tests. The Model Y earned a 5-star rating from Euro NCAP in 2022, while the Model S received a 5-star rating from the NHTSA from 2013 to 2022. These ratings reflect the vehicles’ robust structural integrity, advanced driver assistance systems, and comprehensive airbag coverage.
Both models come equipped with Tesla’s Autopilot system, which includes features such as adaptive cruise control, lane keeping assist, and automatic emergency braking. The Model S also offers additional safety features like a more advanced suite of sensors and cameras, providing a higher level of automation and enhanced situational awareness. However, it’s worth noting that both vehicles are equipped with Tesla’s Full Self-Driving (FSD) capability, which is available as an optional upgrade and enables features like automatic lane changes, summon, and traffic light recognition.
The Model Y and Model S are also designed with pedestrian safety in mind, featuring an active hood that reduces injury risk in the event of a collision. Both vehicles are constructed with a rigid aluminum and high-strength steel frame, providing excellent protection in the event of an accident.
Conclusion
In summary, the Tesla Model Y Long Range AWD 75kWh and the Tesla Model S 75 cater to different needs and preferences. The Model Y is the better choice for those who prioritize practicality, space, and modern SUV styling, making it ideal for families or those who require extra cargo capacity. Its superior range, faster charging, and more versatile interior make it a compelling option for long-distance travel and daily commuting alike.
The Model S, on the other hand, is designed for those who seek a more luxurious and refined driving experience. Its sleek sedan profile, premium materials, and advanced infotainment system offer a more traditional yet high-tech approach to electric mobility. While it may not match the Model Y in terms of practicality or range, it offers a more engaging driving experience with its higher top speed and superior ride quality.
Ultimately, the choice between the Tesla Model Y Long Range AWD 75kWh and the Tesla Model S 75 comes down to your specific needs and preferences. Both models exemplify Tesla’s commitment to innovation and performance, and either would be a worthy addition to any EV enthusiast’s garage.